Mechanical Mystery
Is
that used car trash or treasure?
by Terry Jackson
The lady on the phone was quite serious: “I
have a 1962 Buick Invicta four-door sedan in my garage that
belonged to my late husband,’’ she said. “He bought it new and
kept it up very nice. I’ve been holding on to it as an
investment and now I want to sell it. How much should I ask?’’
Oh, dearie me. How to break the bad news to this nice person? I
checked recent auction results for Invicta sales and the results
weren’t encouraging. Depending on condition, this lady’s Invicta
might bring less than $2,000. The upside might be as high as
$7,000, but don’t count on it.
“That little?’’ she said. “But it’s a classic. I thought old
cars were going up in value.’’
Therein is the dilemma of hanging on to an old car in the belief
it will provide serious financial returns down the road. For
every story of someone who sees a $100,000 windfall on a
pristine 1967 Shelby GT 500 they’ve owned since new, there are
hundreds of stories of people who are shocked to find that the
car they’ve stored in their garage for decades is just a dusty,
used car.
Here are 10 rules everyone should follow when it comes to buying
or keeping an old car:
-
There’s no magic point at which an old car
becomes collectible. Age doesn’t translate into value. A
10-year-old Mustang will not automatically be more valuable
when it’s 20 years old. A 40-year-old Chevrolet won’t
necessarily be more valuable when it turns 50. A wide range of
circumstances combine to make an old car an appreciating
asset: How many were built, the car’s desirability when it was
new, etc.
-
Four-door sedans rarely
become valuable. Cars with four doors are the utilitarian
vehicles of the automotive world, usually designed to be more
practical than provocative. It almost never pays to hang onto
a four-door sedan. They almost always will be regarded as just
used cars.
-
Convertibles are the stars. There’s a saying
in the collector car game: Interest (and prices) goes up when
the top goes down. Convertibles are automotive sex symbols and
as we all know, sex sells. If that old car in your garage is a
ragtop, you’ve got a possible contender.
-
Options add value. The more extras that were
on the car when it was new, the better. A car from the 1960s
or ‘50s with power windows and seats was something of a
rarity, particularly in a Ford or Chevy. So a 1963 Impala
convertible with all the power options would be a keeper.
-
The more power the better. It may not be
economically or environmentally appropriate, but an old car
with a powerful, optional V8 will almost always bring more
money than the same car equipped with the standard V8 or
economy six.
-
Originality counts. Collectors pay top dollar
for cars that haven’t been modified in any way. To get the
most money for a collector car it’s crucial that it still have
the original engine and transmission. Rebuilding those
components adds value, but the basic parts should be the ones
installed at the factory.
-
Never buy a “project’’ car. It’s tempting to
look at a cheap old car that’s in need of a complete
restoration and think it’s a bargain. Quickly run away from
such deals. Unless you’re a master mechanic with too much time
on your hands, restoring an old car is almost never
economically feasible. Just check the ads that say, “More than
$50,000 invested,’’ and the seller is asking $25,000.
-
Buy the best car you can afford. This is
really the inverse of the previous tip. While you should avoid
restoration projects, you should buy the most perfect car you
can. It will retain its value better and need minimal
additional investment.
-
Buy a car you love. One of the mistakes people
make is they buy a car that they don’t really covet and then
become disappointed when they can’t quickly sell it for a big
profit. But if you buy a car that you’ve always wanted to own,
it doesn’t really matter how quickly you can turn a profit.
You’ll be happy to own the car no matter what the market does.
-
Cars are meant to be driven. The tragedy that
befalls many old cars - the collectible queens and the aged
survivors - is that they sit in garages and are treated like
sculptures. Cars are meant to be driven, even if only for a
couple of afternoons a month. Driving a well-maintained
classic provides a thrill that makes any talk of eventual
financial windfall irrelevant.
(Terry Jackson, AMI Auto World’s editor-in-chief, is a
sometimes collector and closely follows the collector car
market.)
© 2002 American Media, Inc. All Rights
Reserved
|